Contact Us

Immigration

About Us

Contact Us

Free Quote

Impact of Absence on Citizenship Eligibility

Impact of Absence on Citizenship Eligibility

Understanding how absences from Ireland affect citizenship eligibility is essential for applicants seeking naturalisation. While some flexibility exists, exceeding the permitted absence limit may lead to refusal.

Absence Limitations in the Year Before Application

The last year spent in Ireland prior to a Citizenship Application must be an unbroken period of residency. In this year, applicants must not be absent from the State for more than six weeks. Some exceptions may apply, such as work-related travel, family emergencies, or medical treatment.

Applicants should provide a detailed explanation of any absences, along with supporting documentation, in their application. Any absence exceeding six weeks must be justified.

Legal Challenge to the Six-Week Rule

Immigration Solicitors, on behalf of client Roderick Jones, challenged the six-week absence rule in the High Court. The case was later brought before the Court of Appeal, which issued a significant ruling on the interpretation of continuous residence for naturalisation.

The Six-Week Absence Rule in Citizenship and Naturalisation Cases

High Court Ruling on Continuous Residence

In July 2019, Mr. Justice Max Barrett of the High Court ruled that the Minister for Justice’s discretionary practice of allowing applicants six weeks of absence was not permitted under section 15(1)(c) of the Irish Nationality and Citizenship Act 1956 (as amended). The court held that continuous residence required uninterrupted presence in the State, without even a single night’s absence over the 365-day period.

Court of Appeal Decision

In November 2019, the Court of Appeal overturned the High Court’s decision, stating that:

  • The interpretation of “continuous residence” requiring uninterrupted presence was unworkable, overly rigid, and led to an absurd outcome.
  • The High Court’s ruling created an obstacle to naturalisation that most applicants could not meet.
  • The term “continuous residence” differs from “ordinary residence” and should not be interpreted as an absolute prohibition on travel.
  • The Oireachtas (Irish legislature) intended for physical presence in the State to be significant but not absolute.

Minister’s Six-Week Absence Policy

The Court of Appeal upheld the Minister’s policy, stating that:

  • Applicants are generally allowed six weeks of absence for work or personal reasons, with longer absences considered in exceptional circumstances.
  • The policy is reasonable, flexible, and does not impose an unlawful barrier to naturalisation.
  • The Minister’s approach provides clarity and certainty for applicants, ensuring a practical interpretation of the law.

Final Ruling on the Case

The court concluded that the Minister for Justice acted correctly in refusing the applicant’s naturalisation due to excessive absences. It found that most of the applicant’s absences were not work-related, making them significant in the eligibility assessment.