Contact Us

Immigration

About Us

Contact Us

Free Quote

Citizenship Application Denials Due to Security Issues

Citizenship Application Denials Due to Security Issues

Irish citizenship applications can be refused for various reasons, including national security concerns. In response to this, a Single Person Committee of Inquiry has been established to provide applicants with a process to seek disclosure of the information used in refusal decisions.

Establishment of a Single Person Committee of Inquiry

On 30th September 2020, the Minister for Justice and Equality, Helen McEntee, announced the formation of a Single Person Committee of Inquiry to review refusals of Irish citizenship applications based on national security concerns.

Role of the Committee

The committee is led by Mr. Justice John Hedigan, a retired judge with extensive experience in the High Court, Court of Appeal, and European Court of Human Rights. Its primary function is to assess requests for disclosure of information related to citizenship application refusals on security grounds.

Process for Seeking Disclosure of Information

Understanding the steps involved in seeking disclosure is crucial for applicants who wish to challenge the refusal of their Irish citizenship due to national security concerns. The process follows a structured approach to ensure transparency while maintaining national security interests.

Eligibility to Request Disclosure

From 30th September 2020 onwards, any applicant whose citizenship has been refused, either wholly or partially, due to national security concerns may request disclosure of the information used in the decision. This initiative aims to provide applicants with a fair opportunity to understand and respond to the reasoning behind their refusal.

Steps to Apply for Disclosure

To initiate the disclosure request, applicants must follow a specific procedure set by the committee:

  1. The applicant must submit a written request to the committee within three months of receiving the refusal decision.
  2. The committee member will assess the request and recommend one of the following:
    • No disclosure of the information.
    • Partial disclosure, with an indicative wording outlining the “gist” of the information.
    • Full disclosure of the information.
  3. The Minister for Justice will review the recommendation but will retain the final authority on whether and how much information is disclosed.

Concerns Regarding the Committee’s Structure

While the introduction of a disclosure mechanism is a step forward, there are valid concerns about the way the committee has been structured. Critics argue that a single-person committee may lack the level of scrutiny and independence that a multi-member panel could provide.

Limitations of the Inquiry Process

Although this process allows applicants to seek disclosure, it is limited to cases involving national security concerns. Individuals who have been refused Irish citizenship for other reasons—such as previous criminal convictions, extended absences from the State, or other discretionary grounds—are not eligible for this process. Instead, they may need to explore legal alternatives, including judicial review or other available remedies.